Mind over money: Navigating the psychology of investing

The psychology of investing is an area of study within behavioural finance that seeks to understand the cognitive and emotional factors influencing investors' decision-making. Behavioural finance researchers have observed that investors are not always rational and may make decisions based on factors that are not directly related to the fundamental value of the underlying assets. This realisation has implications for the efficient functioning of financial markets and can lead to market inefficiencies and asset price bubbles. In this article, we look at the theories and biases involved. 

Prospect theory is a prominent model which posits that investors evaluate potential gains and losses relative to a reference point and that losses loom larger than gains of the same magnitude. This can lead investors to be risk-averse in the face of potential losses and risk-seeking in the face of potential gains. For example, an investor may be reluctant to sell a losing stock because they fear the pain of regret or feel committed to the stock based on prior investment decisions. 

Behavioural portfolio theory is another potentially significant influence that suggests investors construct their portfolios based on their beliefs and attitudes towards risk, rather than based on the expected returns and standard deviation of the underlying assets. This can lead to suboptimal asset allocation decisions and ultimately impact investment performance. An investor may overweigh stocks in their portfolio that are in a sector they are familiar with, rather than diversifying across different sectors, even though the expected returns of the familiar sector are not higher than other sectors. 

Terrance Odean, Professor of Finance at UC Berkeley's Haas School of Business, comments: "Human beings are not well equipped to be rational and objective when making investment decisions. Instead, we are prone to a variety of cognitive and emotional biases that can lead us astray. The challenge for investors is to recognise and overcome these biases in order to make sound investment decisions." 

Several common psychological biases can impact investment decisions.  

The anchoring bias refers to the tendency to rely too heavily on the first piece of information encountered when making a decision, even if that information is not relevant. An investor may rely on the price of a stock from a month ago to estimate its current value, even if there have been significant developments since that time.  

Overconfidence bias refers to the tendency to overestimate one's abilities and the accuracy of one's beliefs and predictions, so an investor may believe they have a superior ability to pick winning stocks, leading them to trade frequently and incur transaction costs that eat into their returns.  

Confirmation bias refers to the tendency to seek out information that confirms pre-existing beliefs and to ignore or discount information that contradicts those beliefs. Investors may overweight their investments in a certain sector, even when new information suggests that the sector is declining, because they believe it will eventually rebound. 

Understanding the psychology of investing is essential for investors, financial advisors, and market participants. By anticipating and responding to market inefficiencies and behavioural biases, these individuals can make more informed investment decisions, which can lead to improved investment outcomes and ultimately, to ensure the efficient functioning of financial markets. 

While the study of the psychology of investing can be a complex and technical subject, it's important to remember that investing is ultimately about achieving financial security and avoiding significant losses. As financial journalist Jean Chatzky once quipped, "Know what's better than a million dollars? A billion dollars. Know what's better than a billion dollars? Not losing your shirt."  

Polymath & Boffin is a knowledge equity investor, a visionary, and a creator of bespoke commercial solutions. Our mission is to connect investor capital with innovative product and commercial opportunity, establishing an ecosystem of commerce for both investee and investor, one which thrives on an alignment of interest between all development partners. 

Let us apply financial acumen, science and creativity to the growth of your business.